Thursday, December 6, 2012
Does Gloria Really Want to Test the Narrator?
After reading Queenpin, one of the plot details that
stuck with me is how Gloria keeps the narrator’s bloody dress after Vic’s murder.
We mentioned this detail in class, but I wanted to further explore this plot
point since I think it reveals a lot about the role perspective plays in the
novel. As soon as the narrator discovers the dress, I just knew that Gloria
would validate keeping the dress through an excuse, but I honestly thought she
was going to plant the dress on Regina and frame her for Vic’s murder.
Once the narrator calls out
Gloria for keeping the dress, Gloria justifies this by saying she was just
holding onto it to make sure the narrator “had her head on straight” (158).
Gloria then says, “What do you think I could be scared of? Nothing you could
throw my way, junior… If I found out you really tangled with me, kid… I think
you’d know what I’d do. I take care of my own business. Right?” (159). Through
this explanation, it really does seem to be a credible excuse for Gloria to
keep the dress to test the narrator, but a few of the plot details invalidate
this claim. Initially, if Gloria wanted to test the narrator, why wouldn’t she leave
more pieces of evidence for the narrator to find? Gloria doesn’t leave any evidence
that could pin the murder on herself; she only leaves the dress as the one
piece of evidence that could incriminate the narrator. Also, once Gloria is
aware that the dress is missing, why does she leave the closet open for the
narrator to see that the dress is gone? The only purpose this serves is to
threaten the narrator to show her that Gloria knows she took the dress. The
final piece of evidence going against Gloria is that she doesn’t tell the
narrator that she knows that the dress is missing. If she was really testing
her, she should have congratulated the narrator for passing her test and discovering
the dress.
Through this justification, it
seems to me that Gloria held onto the dress as a way to blackmail the narrator,
but to counter this assertion, Gloria does seem to be too methodical in her
planning to leave the dress in a spot where the narrator could easily find it,
like the back of a closet. And also, at the novel’s end, Gloria seems to be too appreciative of the narrator through giving her a new letter opener to want to
blackmail her.
This uncertainty about Gloria’s
intentions is one of the details that I really love about the book. As a reader,
I doubted whether or not Gloria was trustworthy throughout the entirety of the
novel. This uncertainty and doubt can be attributed to Abbott’s writing style
since she leaves most of the interpretation about the characters open to the
reader. Any analysis of plot details is subjective through the narrator’s
perspective, and I think that a lot of scenarios in the novel could be analyzed
in different ways.
I was wondering if anyone had any
thoughts about Gloria keeping the dress, or if someone could argue that Gloria
really meant to keep the dress as a test for the narrator.
Wednesday, December 5, 2012
Gloria's Toughness
We kind of touched on it the other day in class, that Gloria and the protagonist have to be much more tough than the men that surround them. They have to go above and beyond in order to prove themselves. I definitely understood why Gloria acted the way she did and was the way she was. For example, when she kills Vic and the men come in to clean up they are shocked. The narrator mentions that the look on Gloria's face is one of satisfaction. I felt like this was the ultimate example of Gloria trying to be bigger and better than the boys because she was so proud that these men who have seen it all, couldn't believe what they walked into, and that a woman did it.
I also have to say I really liked Gloria. I know that she is a criminal and yada yada yada but in the context of the novel, she was pretty badass. Even in the ending, when she realizes what's going on, she's so calm about it and then just slits her throat. \m/
Lastly, I couldn't help but feel that the narrator took Gloria down too soon. I guess it was circumstantial but I kind of felt like she wasn't really ready for the crime world on her own. Up until the end, she was still making mistakes. I think she handled herself with the cops/Regina pretty well but she didn't realize that Vic had pulled one over on her until Gloria lays it out. Maybe the intuition that Gloria has will come with time and experience.
I also have to say I really liked Gloria. I know that she is a criminal and yada yada yada but in the context of the novel, she was pretty badass. Even in the ending, when she realizes what's going on, she's so calm about it and then just slits her throat. \m/
Lastly, I couldn't help but feel that the narrator took Gloria down too soon. I guess it was circumstantial but I kind of felt like she wasn't really ready for the crime world on her own. Up until the end, she was still making mistakes. I think she handled herself with the cops/Regina pretty well but she didn't realize that Vic had pulled one over on her until Gloria lays it out. Maybe the intuition that Gloria has will come with time and experience.
The Role of Femme Fatales
I liked how Queenpin reversed the stereotypical role of women in noir by making a man into the "femme fatale" (known as the "homme fatale") character of the story. It was refreshing to see at least one female character (Gloria) who was empowered and did not have to rely on her sexuality to manipulate others to get ahead. It seems that Abbott used the Vic character to counteract all the misogynistic portrayals of women in previous noir by making him into a general loser; however, his sexual power over the unnamed narrator complicates this notion. Since the narrator is the one who wins at the end of the novel, I wonder what commentary Abbott is making about how the quest for power for females is different than it is for males. It seems to me that Abbott is showing the ugly reality of how women must serve their own self interests and align themselves with men in order to become more powerful and wealthy. Gloria's attempt to create a feminist/"girl power" loyalty between her and the narrator ultimately failed, and even though the narrator felt bad about betraying Gloria, she ultimately decided to anyways. I think it would be useful for the exam to compare the role of Vic in the novel compared to the typical role of the femme fatale in noir and how he is written differently, so if anyone cares to elaborate, go ahead...
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Dialogue In Queenpin
As we've seen throughout the semester, the noir style uses action
and fast-paced dialogue to advance the plot, and Queenpin is no exception to this characteristic. I found the novel
to be a speedy read due to the clever dialogue and fast paced interactions
between the characters.
So, I have to ask, what particular scenes or
interactions did you find clever or amusing within the novel? I particularly
liked this exchange between the narrator and the man that is hired to test her
loyalty at the racetrack:
“That’s a nice hat you have, miss,” he said, standing in the
row behind me.
“Thanks,” I said, turning slightly, tucking my purse tight
under my arm. “I’ll tell it you said so.”
"Double Indemnity" at Happy Hour
Ok, so I know everybody is stressing out right now as classes are abruptly coming to an end and, if your anything like me and my friends, some happy hour/going out to eat action can really recharge the batteries. So tonight while I was attempting to reboot a bit before continuing work, it seems that a Temple student during finals can't truly escape their fate of looming finals. As we sat down, the bar was playing, as the title suggests, "Double Indemnity". I literally just had to laugh. I have to admit that "Double Indemnity" is still one of my favorite things that we have looked at so far this semester and, I know that I've seen a couple of polls about who liked what, but I figure I'll ask again. What was everybody's favorite film/book/character/whatever that we looked at with Lukin this semester?
Random and not very educational, I know, but don't worry guys, the semester is almost over.
Random and not very educational, I know, but don't worry guys, the semester is almost over.
Christy Wampole's Irony- What's the problem?
I'd like to know, what do people find so wrong with Wampole's article "How to Live Without Irony"?
Overall I find it to be pretty true and similar to my own views.
I can understand that maybe her publication has been scrutinized so thoroughly that the essence of her point has been overlooked.. but honestly I don't see what the big turn-off is in her writing.
Here's a link
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/17/how-to-live-without-irony/
Overall I find it to be pretty true and similar to my own views.
I can understand that maybe her publication has been scrutinized so thoroughly that the essence of her point has been overlooked.. but honestly I don't see what the big turn-off is in her writing.
Here's a link
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/17/how-to-live-without-irony/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)